Conrad’s ‘Nigger’: High art through the lens
of racial tension, a review of ‘The Nigger of the Narcissus’
by Joe McCarthy
In all sea-going tales one finds a common
thread of symbolism pointing to a larger dilemma or ‘grand narrative’ in which
the author probes the crevices of the human soul and sees his worldview
exemplified. Melville’s Moby Dick portrays the tortured themes of
obsession and redemption as personified in Captain Ahab in his quest for the
great whale: his pursuit ending in lamentable tragedy, as all such ill advised
grail-like endeavors must; the message being that the redemptive urge must be
tempered by the golden mean of balanced equilibrium lest the path taken end in
madding, obsessive destruction.
Equally exalted though distinctly poignant
themes are pursued by that master of sea borne adventure, the Anglicized
Polish novelist Joseph Conrad (born Teodor Josef Konrad Korzeniowski) in his
awkwardly titled (at least to modern eyes) story The Nigger of the
Narcissus, which is best understood as an attempt by the author to deliver
both a homily and tribute to that capacity within the human soul which enables
the creation of art that transcends yet simultaneously allows man to see life
in all its gritty reality. Perhaps Conrad’s descriptive soliloquy in
describing the point of his enterprise manifests when he says in his preface
that art, which necessarily includes his own, "appeals primarily to the
senses, and the artistic aim when expressing itself in written words must also
make its appeal through the senses, if its high desire is to reach the secret
spring of the responsive emotions."
This appeal to the emotive can be said to be
the hallmark of the artist’s purpose, in contradistinction to the more
dispassionate, rational discourse of the theoretical. Keats said it best in a
letter to John Hamilton Reynolds in noting that "extensive knowledge is
needful to thinking people - it takes away the heat and fever;" yet in
converse to this he recognized that it is precisely this "heat and fever"
which is lacking in the realm of pure reason as he went on to observe that it
is "impossible to know how far Knowledge will console us for the death of a
friend…" This understanding of the need for that which reaches into the pores
of human experience and extracts depth and feeling is the keystone to a truly
ascendant art.
Our tale centers around one James Wait, a black
crewmen who is reviled by the other members aboard the ship Narcissus - an
ocean going vessel embarking on a voyage from Bombay to London. The general
tone in regards to feeling on board toward Wait can be seen in the narration
that he "became the tormentor of all our moments; he was worse than a
nightmare. You couldn’t see that there was anything wrong with him: a nigger
does not show. He was not very fat — certainly — but then he was no leaner
than other niggers we had known."
The theme of strong racial resentment, mutually
held by both Wait and the other members of the ship, is developed further in
the clash between Wait and Belfast: "Belfast approached our nigger with great
fury," upon which Wait responds to Belfast in taunting derision - "you little
Irish lunatic, you!" The predictable melee follows, with Wait ending up on his
back, overlooked by a steaming adversary: "We expected Belfast to strangle
Wait without more ado. Dust flew. We heard it through the nigger’s cough,
metallic and explosive like a gong. Next moment we saw Belfast hanging over
him."
The principle that like attracts like and that
‘birds of a feather flock together,’ is given its motive force in Wait’s
disappointment upon finding that the Narcissus has a white cook: "Again he was
heard asking: ‘Is your cook a coloured gentleman?’ Then a disappointed and
disapproving ‘Ah! h’m!’ was his comment upon the information that the cook
happened to be a mere white man."
Over five decades after the court dictated end
of state sanctioned school segregation, where blacks continue to voluntarily
self-segregate themselves in school cafeterias, and where various in your face
racial clubs are seen on campus, perhaps Conrad can help us to see that there
is something natural in one’s Being which demands that a person’s sense of
self is undergirded with a pride in belonging to a distinct race or group,
even if such a fact makes liberals wince.
What struck this writer most in reading this
work, beyond the overarching racial struggle, is the microcosm of larger
events that it articulates. Aboard a small ship, traveling through the Indian
Ocean, we are witness to an allegory demonstrating the futility of
multicultural do-goodism, which seeks to artificially thrust disparate peoples
together, ignoring the inherent Darwinian ’struggle for life’ between
varieties of the same species. Indeed, The Nigger even contains
instances of the whites on the ship insulting each other in ethnically tinged
slurs, thus adding even further validation to the theorem of the inherent
hostility found toward the ‘other’, which post-structuralists such as Derrida
would prefer be glossed over, yet nonetheless is undoubtedly with us. The
underlying current, seen time and again in Thomas Sowell’s celebrated trilogy
on race and its relation to culture, is that societies, which Conrad’s book
can be seen as a representation of in the micro, featuring ‘diverse’ cultures
can only exist in one of two ways, to wit: with the dominant group in a
position of oppressive empowerment over the weaker, or with the divergent
groups in a state of turmoil. This, Conrad’s story demonstrates powerfully, if
subliminally. The ship’s crew are sent into an uproar, for want of
homogeneity, and what is true in this fictional account aboard a ship
featuring what Conrad describes as the "obscure lives of a few individuals out
of all the disregarded multitude," is true as well in the real life society at
large. Art as a reflection of the reality of the bitter underbelly of human
intercourse is ultimately Conrad's message, and we'd be wise to heed it.